The Importance of Language

Language is the main method of human communication, but what happens when all language is lost? There is only one way to find out, I took to talking to a close friend of mine by simple hand gestures. My plan was to communicate about plans for the weekend, this started with walking towards a calendar and pointing at Saturday and Sunday. My friend did not understand right away and said phrases like “what about saturday and sunday?” and “why are you pointing at me and then pointing at the calender.” It took a good about of time to finally get across that I was asking about his weekend plans. I would point at him, then point at the calendar, and then back at him, and nod yes or no to his questions. This seemed fairly easy, in the since that I could answer all his questions with a simple head nod, but hard by constantly repeating myself and becoming frustrated.  My friend had mentioned that without the head nods there would be no way to communicate thoroughly and with full understanding. I would say the person in control of this conversation was me because without my head nods of yes or no the conversation would have gone nowhere. I asked my friend this same questions and got an answer of him feeling in control, he said how he had control of the questions so moreover, he was in control.

After he realized what I was asking him, he answered and followed up with a question, “what are you doing over the weekend.” This was hard to answer because I couldn't think of how to get my message across to him. I googled a picture of the beach and showed him, this seemed to be the most logical way to say “i'm going to the beach.” Without my cellphone, this task  would have been challenging. The majority of this experiment he asked the questions and would answer with a head shake. I feel as in this situation he had the power because he could ask the questions and all I had to do was reply with an answer. A culture that has complex ideals when it comes to the unspoken and spoken language would be the deaf. Using sign language with another person who also knows sign language is a universal way for those who are incapable to communicate. I believe that people should go out of their way to explore sign language and any languages for that matter. You never know what situation you could run into and have there be a barrier between cultures. A modern situation could be people speaking spanish in California, where mostly english is spoken. If people learned spanish we could have a bilingual culture all together and not have there be a separation. This experience showed that humans heavily rely on physical body movements when it comes to communication, it enhances and gives a better understanding to verbal communication.

Non-speech language is so important in today society because we could use it as a form of communicating overall. Humans can learn all types of information from simple body gestures. For example, someone sitting across the room with a straight face and arms crossed most likely does not want to be spoken too, but this is just how us humans read it, body gestures are simply everything in today’s world. But what happens when gestures are taken away?

Being able to speak and communicate is one thing, but having body movement sets the tone for the mood I am in when  talking. For this part of the assignment, I talked to someone who had no clue I was doing an experiment. We talked about the Bachelor and about the new Bachelorette, this person constantly asked me “are you okay?” and “is there something going on.” They did not have a difficult time understanding me but more of a hard time wondering why I was just simply sitting there. I have found after conducting this experiment that humans automatically assume something is wrong when body movements are not involved. The ability to read body language is so important because it can answer questions without even speaking. I believe reading body language can also send the wrong signals, someone could be sitting and enjoying their day and the person walking by could think they are upset or mad. Body language plays a large role in society as well as the language itself.

Comments

  1. My speaking partner was constantly asking me if I was okay too, and whether or not something was happening, when I was doing the second part of the experiment. Your analysis of why was so well written! And a good point! When there's a lack of expression, in the face or body, I immediately think something's wrong, and I start to feel paranoia because I can't understand the signals. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Part 1:
    Could you respond with body language beyond nodding or shaking your head? Many students say this is a lot like a game of charades, which usually goes far beyond moving your head.

    I appreciate that you asked your partner about the issue of control, but how did *you* feel in this part of the experiment with regard to power and control in this conversation? What did it feel like to NOT have control or power in the conversation?

    "A culture that has complex ideals when it comes to the unspoken and spoken language would be the deaf."

    This was a two-part question. The first asked which culture (speaking or non-speaking) would have the advantage in communicating complex *ideas* (not "ideals"). Back up and understand what "complex ideas" actually are. Would you be able to explain Darwin's theory of natural selection or Einstein's theory of relativity without symbolic language? I don't think I could. If body language was better at communicating these complex ideas, we wouldn't need spoken symbolic language. Because symbolic language is pervasive in all cultures, that tells us that it is advantageous in communication, particularly with concepts that are just ideas and not things to demonstrate and show.

    Second, it asked you to identify a real-life situation that mirrored the conditions you experienced in this experiment. To find a real life example of this experiment, we need to find a situation where you have a speaking population and another group that doesn't speak that language, and this results in a power differential, with the speaking culture having power over the non-speaking (which is why the question on power and control from your perspective was important). You actually offer two valid examples here, the deaf community and the immigrant community.

    Part 2:
    When all your points are collapsed into one paragraph, it makes it difficult to parse out your responses to each prompt. It is to your advantage to ensure that your answers are clearly indicated. Separate each set of guideline prompts into separate paragraphs. These sections should have expanded and explained fully. Show me what you know.

    Okay on your description of this experiment.

    I'm having great difficulty parsing out where you address various prompts in this section. You seem to discuss the issue of "information gained" from body language, but I don't see where you talk about the selective benefits of using body language, nor the final section (individuals who don't read body language and situations where it might be better to not read body language). Deductions apply as such.

    I don't disagree with your conclusions regarding the information we receive from body language, but you are only considering the situation where body language matches and supports the information you receive from spoken language. What does it tell you when the body language doesn't match the spoken language? Humans tend to use body language as a type of lie detector. If spoken words don't match with the body language, we are more inclined to believe the body language and doubt the words. Think about how being able to detect liars might help an individual's ability to survive and reproduce (which applies to the next section).

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts